
What You’ll Learn
- What human performance tools are for: applied against identified error precursors, they cut the likelihood of an error before it happens
- The graded approach to job planning — five steps scaled to the potential consequences of getting a critical step wrong
- What the pre-job briefing, the job site review, and the post-job review each contribute — before, around, and after the work
- Why following a written procedure step by step, and marking progress as you go, is itself a human performance tool
- When a procedure must be stopped: it cannot be used as written, or its expected result cannot be predicted
Tools That Work on the Setup, Not the Slip
Once a crew can spot error precursors, the next question is what to do about them. The annex’s answer is human performance tools: deliberate work practices that reduce the likelihood of error when they are applied to error precursors. The tools are not exotic. Most are disciplined versions of things good crews already do — plan, brief, look, review, follow the procedure — made explicit so they happen every time instead of when someone remembers. Q.6.1 adds an organizational point: consistent use of the tools across an organization is how best-practice work gets built into normal work. This article covers the first five tools in Q.6 — job planning and the pre-job briefing, the job site review, the post-job review, and procedure use and adherence. A companion article covers the remaining four: self-check with verbalization, three-way communication, stop when unsure, and flagging and blocking.
Job Planning and the Pre-Job Briefing: The Graded Approach
Job planning and the pre-job briefing come first because they set up everything else. Creating a job plan and conducting a pre-job briefing helps personnel focus on performing the tasks and understand their roles in executing them. Annex Q offers a graded approach to the planning itself — “graded” meaning the depth of the planning effort is proportionate to the potential consequences of an error. The approach works through five steps:
- Summarize the critical steps of the job — the steps that, if performed improperly, will cause irreversible harm to persons or equipment, or significantly affect the operation of a process.
- Anticipate the error precursors that attach to each critical step.
- Foresee the probable consequences, and the worst-case consequences, if an error occurs during each critical step.
- Evaluate the controls or contingencies at each critical step that can prevent an error, catch it, or recover from it and reduce its consequences.
- Review previous experience and lessons learned that are relevant to this specific task and its critical steps.
Notice how the sequence thinks. It starts from consequence (which steps can hurt us irreversibly?), moves to likelihood (what precursors are lying in wait at those steps?), and only then to defense (what will prevent, catch, or soften an error there?). If the planning identifies one or more human performance tools for a step, each selected tool is then discussed — its advantages, its disadvantages, and when and how it should be applied — so the tool is chosen deliberately rather than recited.
The Job Site Review: Eyes on the Actual Place
A plan is made from drawings, procedures, and memory. The job site review checks the plan against the physical reality of the workplace. Working a site review into job planning helps the crew identify hazards — and also the potential barriers and delays that will shape how the job actually unfolds. A locked gate, a missing label, a scaffold in the way, a feeder that is not where the drawing says: these are cheap to discover in a review and expensive to discover mid-task with tools in hand. The review is flexible in timing — it can be performed any time before the work or during it — which makes it as useful for a job already underway, when conditions have drifted from the plan, as for one still on paper.
The Post-Job Review: Where the Next Job Gets Safer
The post-job review closes the loop. It is a positive opportunity — the annex’s framing, not a disciplinary one — to capture feedback and lessons learned from the job just finished so they can be applied to future jobs. One specific item belongs in every review: the use, or the lack of use, of human performance tools gets incorporated into it. Did the crew use the tools the plan selected? Did a tool get skipped under time pressure, and did a precursor the plan missed show up anyway? Those answers feed directly back into step five of the next job’s planning — review of previous experience and lessons learned — which is why the annex pairs the two ends of the job together: the pre-job briefing and the post-job review are both called out as effective communication tools, one carrying intent forward into the work, the other carrying experience forward out of it.
Procedure Use and Adherence: The Procedure as a Tool
It is easy to think of a procedure as paperwork that accompanies the real defenses. Annex Q treats procedure use and adherence as a human performance tool in its own right. The practice has several parts. The worker proactively reads the procedure and understands the purpose, scope, and intent of its actions — all of them, as written, and in the sequence specified — rather than skimming for the step that looks familiar. Progress through the procedure is kept current by marking each step as it is completed, which does two jobs at once: it prevents the skipped or duplicated step during the work, and it means that if the procedure is interrupted before all steps are finished, the job site or activity can be left in a safe state and the procedure resumed later at exactly the point where it stopped. And the tool carries its own stop rule: if the procedure cannot be used as written, or if the expected result of following it cannot be accurately predicted, the activity stops and the issues are resolved before work continues. The annex’s example is one electricians know well — a switching sequence, in which the sequential order of operating electrical distribution equipment is identified and documented for de-energizing and re-energizing. In switching, order is not a preference; it is the substance of the procedure, which is exactly why adherence is a tool and not a formality.
Worked Scenario
A crew is assigned a switching job to de-energize a feeder for maintenance, then re-energize it afterward. Planning follows the graded approach. The critical steps are summarized first: opening the correct feeder breaker under load, and later, verifying the right feeder before re-energizing — errors at either one are not easily taken back. For each critical step the crew anticipates precursors: the lineup contains look-alike breakers, the switching order has to be held in sequence, and the work is scheduled against a production restart, so time pressure is present. Worst case is plainly stated — wrong feeder opened, or the wrong feeder re-energized into a work area. Controls are evaluated: the written switching sequence will be used step by step and marked off, and lessons from a previous job — where a similar lineup caused a near wrong-breaker event — are reviewed before anyone leaves the office. The job site review then earns its keep: walking the lineup, the crew finds one breaker label faded to near-illegibility, a discrepancy they resolve against the drawings before switching begins rather than during it. The switching proceeds on the marked-up procedure, and when a radio interruption breaks the sequence midway, work pauses with the equipment left in a safe state and resumes from the last checked step, not from memory. Afterward, the post-job review records the faded label as a defect to be corrected, notes that the interruption protocol worked, and files both lessons where the next crew planning a similar job will find them.
Common Mistakes and Safety Notes
- Planning every job at maximum depth — or none. The approach is graded: the effort should be proportionate to the potential consequences of an error at the critical steps.
- Identifying critical steps but skipping the precursors. The graded approach pairs them deliberately — a critical step without its anticipated precursors is only half planned.
- Treating the job site review as a one-time, pre-work event. It can be performed any time before or during work; conditions drift, and a mid-job review catches the drift.
- Letting the post-job review become a blame session or skipping it when the job went fine. It is a positive opportunity to capture lessons — including whether human performance tools were used or not — and smooth jobs have lessons too.
- Following the procedure from memory and marking it up afterward. Adherence means reading and understanding the steps as written, in sequence, and marking each step as it is completed — the marks are what make an interrupted job safely resumable.
- Pressing on when the procedure doesn’t fit. If the procedure cannot be used as written, or the expected result cannot be predicted, the activity stops until the issue is resolved. That stop is part of the tool, not a failure of it.
Summary
Human performance tools are work practices applied to identified error precursors to reduce the likelihood of error, and an organization that uses them consistently builds best practice into everyday work. The first tools in Q.6 work on the job’s frame: job planning follows a graded approach — summarize the critical steps, anticipate their error precursors, foresee probable and worst-case consequences, evaluate controls and contingencies, and review previous experience and lessons learned — and the pre-job briefing makes sure everyone understands their roles. The job site review checks the plan against the real workplace, before or during the work. The post-job review captures feedback and lessons, including how the tools themselves were used, for the next job. And procedure use and adherence turns the written procedure into an active defense: understand it, follow it in sequence, mark each step as completed, resume safely after interruptions, and stop when it cannot be used as written or its outcome cannot be predicted.
Quick-Check Questions
1. What do human performance tools do, according to Q.6.1?
Answer: They reduce the likelihood of error when applied to error precursors; used consistently by an organization, they help incorporate best-practice work.
2. What are the five steps of the graded approach to job planning?
Answer: Summarize the critical steps; anticipate error precursors for each critical step; foresee probable and worst-case consequences of an error at each step; evaluate controls or contingencies to prevent, catch, and recover from errors; and review previous experience and lessons learned relevant to the task.
3. When can a job site review be performed?
Answer: Any time prior to the work or during it — it facilitates identifying hazards and potential barriers and delays.
4. What specific subject must a post-job review incorporate?
Answer: The use — or the lack of use — of human performance tools on the job, along with feedback and lessons learned for future jobs.
5. During procedure use and adherence, when must the activity be stopped?
Answer: When the procedure cannot be used as written, or when the expected result cannot be accurately predicted — the issues are resolved before continuing.
Based on NFPA 70E (2024), Informative Annex Q, paraphrased for study.
Video lesson for this module is in production — coming soon.
Quiz for this module is being prepared.
Flashcards for this module are being prepared.



