
What You’ll Learn
- How STAR — Stop, Think, Act, Review — slows the hands down to the speed of the brain before an action that cannot be reversed
- What the Panel 12B example shows about verbalizing each step and its expected outcome
- How three-way communication closes the loop between sender and receiver, and when the phonetic alphabet matters
- Why “I think” and “I’m pretty sure” are signals to stop, get direction, and move from knowledge-based back to rule-based thinking
- When to flag a component, when to block one, and why the two tools pair so well on look-alike equipment
Tools for the Moment of Action
The first set of human performance tools in Annex Q works before and around the job: planning, briefing, reviewing, and following the written procedure. This second set works at the point of execution — in the seconds when a hand is actually moving toward a breaker handle, a control button, or a disconnect switch. Human performance tools of this kind exist because most execution errors happen fast, in familiar surroundings, on tasks the worker has done many times before. Each of the four tools in this article attacks that moment differently: one slows the worker down, one confirms the message, one gives permission to halt, and one marks the equipment itself so the right component — and only the right component — gets operated.
STAR: Self-Check with Verbalization
Self-check with verbalization is the tool behind the acronym STAR: Stop, Think, Act, and Review. It is meant for tasks that cannot be reversed — the breaker closure, the switch operation, the step whose result cannot be taken back once it happens. Before, during, and after such a task, the worker stops, thinks, and openly verbalizes what they are about to do, what they are doing, and what they expect to happen. Speaking the action out loud is not ceremony. Verbalizing lets the brain slow down to the speed of the body: the spoken words force the worker to stay focused on this step, on this component, instead of running ahead on habit. That focus is what enables the worker to act deliberately and then review whether the result matched the expectation.
The Panel 12B Example: Say It Before You Do It
The annex’s worked example shows STAR aimed at the two most ordinary error precursors there are: task demands — the worker is in a hurry, with one more routine task before the end of shift — and human nature — complacency, the quiet assumption that a familiar job cannot surprise you. The task is to close one circuit breaker in a group of motor control panels. Because the worker verbalizes each step and its expected outcome, he is far less likely to operate the wrong breaker, and he is ready if the outcome does not match what he said it would be. The self-check runs like this: the worker states that he is at Panel 12 Bravo (12B); that he is about to close Circuit Breaker 4 Bravo (4B); that the pump motor heater indicator light will engage bright red on Panel 10 Bravo (10B); that the pump motor should not start; and that if the pump motor does start, he will open Circuit Breaker 4 Bravo again. Only then does he announce that he is closing Circuit Breaker 4 Bravo — and close it. Notice what the verbalization bought: the panel and breaker are named precisely, the expected indication is predicted in advance, the abnormal outcome is named too, and the recovery action is decided before it is needed. If the wrong panel had been in front of him, the words would not have matched the labels his eyes were reading — and that mismatch is the error being caught.
Three-Way Communication: Say It, Repeat It, Confirm It
Three-way communication fixes a different failure: the message that was sent but not received as intended. The tool builds mutual understanding between a sender and a receiver in three moves. First, the sender issues a directive or statement. Second, the receiver repeats the message back, confirming the accuracy of what was heard. Third, the sender validates that the proper response was understood — “That is correct,” or “Affirmative.” The annex’s example is a radio directive: “Close circuit breaker 4 Bravo.” The receiver repeats, “I understand, close circuit breaker 4 Bravo,” and the sender closes the loop with the confirmation. When a message includes letters — and electrical work is full of them, in panel, breaker, and feeder designations — the letters should be communicated using the phonetic alphabet whenever possible, so that a B and a D are never confused over a noisy radio. A directive that is not repeated back is a directive whose accuracy nobody has checked.
Stop When Unsure: The Questioning Attitude
Stop when unsure is the tool that turns doubt into an action. When a worker cannot follow a procedure or process step, when something unexpected occurs, or when the worker simply has a gut feeling that something is not right, the correct move is to stop and obtain further direction. The tool rests on a questioning attitude maintained at all times — a standing refusal to push through uncertainty on a critical task. The annex names the tell-tale phrases: “I think” and “I’m pretty sure,” whether spoken aloud or not, indicate that the worker is operating in knowledge-based mode — improvising from an incomplete mental picture — and needs to transition back to rule-based mode, where a procedure or a direction governs the next step. That transition should be communicated to co-workers, so the whole crew knows the basis of the work has changed. Stopping is not an admission of weakness; it is the tool working exactly as designed.
Flagging and Blocking: Mark the Right One, Guard the Wrong Ones
Flagging is a method to make sure the correct component is the one manipulated or worked on, at the required time and under the required conditions. A flag can be a marker, a label, or a device attached to the equipment to be operated. Blocking is its physical counterpart: a method of preventing access to an area or to equipment controls. Hinged covers over control buttons or switches, barricades, fences, and other physical barriers — temporary or permanent — are all blocking tools. Flagging is called for when an error-likely situation or condition is present, such as similar or look-alike equipment, work on multiple components, frequent operations performed in a short period of time, or an interruption of process-critical equipment. Blocking can be used in conjunction with flagging: the flag says “operate this one,” and the block makes the wrong ones hard to touch. (The standard’s flagging provision is cross-referenced at 130.8(O).)
Worked Scenario
A night-shift electrician is sent to a substation yard to open one of two identical feeder disconnects standing side by side — same manufacturer, same vintage, handles at the same height, labels weathered. The error precursors stack up: look-alike equipment, time pressure from an outage clock, and a task done so often it invites skill-based autopilot. She works the tools in combination. First, flagging: the disconnect to be operated gets a bright flag on its handle, and its neighbor gets blocked with a barricade and a hinged cover guard so a hand cannot land on it casually. The switching order arrives by radio, and she runs three-way communication — the operator’s directive is repeated back word for word, feeder letter spelled phonetically, and confirmed before she moves. At the flagged disconnect she runs STAR out loud: stop at the handle, think through the step, state the feeder designation and the expected indication, then act and review the result against what she predicted. Halfway through her verbalization she catches herself naming the adjacent feeder’s number — the flag and the mismatch between her words and the flag stop the error cold, before any handle moves. She re-checks the order, confirms by radio, and completes the operation on the correct disconnect. No single tool did that alone; the flag made the target visible, the repeat-back made the instruction certain, and the self-check caught the slip while it was still just words.
Common Mistakes and Safety Notes
- Doing STAR silently. The tool is self-check with verbalization — speaking the step and its expected outcome aloud is what slows the brain to body speed and exposes a mismatch.
- Skipping the expected outcome. Naming only the action (“closing breaker 4B”) misses half the tool: predict the indication, and decide in advance what you will do if the outcome is wrong.
- Treating a sent message as a received message. Without the receiver’s repeat-back and the sender’s confirmation, a directive’s accuracy has never been checked — use the phonetic alphabet for letter designations.
- Pushing through “I’m pretty sure.” Those words signal knowledge-based mode. Stop, obtain further direction, shift back to rule-based work, and tell your co-workers the mode has changed.
- Flagging without blocking on look-alike gear. A flag identifies the right component; a block physically guards the wrong ones. On similar equipment, use them together.
- Reserving the tools for big jobs. The Panel 12B example is one routine breaker at the end of a shift — hurry and complacency are exactly when these tools earn their keep.
Summary
The second set of Annex Q tools protects the moment of execution. STAR — Stop, Think, Act, Review — has the worker verbalize each step and its expected outcome before, during, and after an irreversible task, so a mismatch between words and equipment is caught while it can still be corrected. Three-way communication closes the loop on every directive: sender states, receiver repeats, sender confirms — with the phonetic alphabet for letters. Stop when unsure converts doubt into direction: a worker who cannot follow a step, sees something unexpected, or feels something is wrong stops, gets further direction, and shifts from knowledge-based guessing back to rule-based work, telling co-workers of the change. Flagging marks the component to be operated and blocking physically prevents access to the ones that must not be touched — a pair built for look-alike equipment, multiple components, and rapid repeated operations.
Quick-Check Questions
1. What does STAR stand for, and why does the worker speak out loud?
Answer: Stop, Think, Act, and Review. Verbalizing the action slows the brain to body speed, keeps the worker focused, and lets them act and then review against the expected outcome.
2. In the Panel 12B example, what two error precursors is the worker facing?
Answer: Task demands — he is in a hurry to finish before the end of shift — and human nature — complacency on a routine task.
3. What are the three moves in three-way communication?
Answer: The sender issues the directive, the receiver repeats it back to confirm accuracy, and the sender validates that the proper response was understood.
4. A worker catches himself thinking “I’m pretty sure this is the right step.” What does that signal, and what should happen?
Answer: It signals knowledge-based mode. He should stop when unsure, obtain further direction, transition back to rule-based mode, and communicate that transition to co-workers.
5. Name two situations that call for flagging.
Answer: Any two of: similar or look-alike equipment; work on multiple components; frequent operations performed in a short period of time; interruption of process critical equipment.
Based on NFPA 70E (2024), Informative Annex Q, paraphrased for study.
Video lesson for this module is in production — coming soon.
Quiz for this module is being prepared.
Flashcards for this module are being prepared.



