
What You’ll Learn
- Why the voltage ranges in Column 1 are drawn where they are — and why the top of each range is a maximum voltage, not the nominal one
- The ×1.732 rule for placing a single-phase system in the right voltage range
- Where each distance column gets its numbers: OSHA’s 10 ft rule, the NEC working-space tables, and OSHA 1910.269 Tables R-6 and R-7
- The two ingredients inside every approach distance — an air-insulation withstand distance plus an inadvertent-movement factor
- Why the restricted approach boundary at 151–750 V is 1 ft in NFPA 70E when OSHA’s own table arithmetic gives 1.09 ft
Numbers With a Paper Trail
Open Tables 130.4(E)(a) and 130.4(E)(b) and you find columns of distances that can look arbitrary: why this many feet at this voltage, and why does the number jump where it does? Informative Annex C.2 answers that question. Annex C is informative — it is not part of the requirements of NFPA 70E — but C.2 documents how the distances in the tables were selected, column by column, so the person doing a shock risk assessment can see what each number is built from. The short version: no column was invented for 70E. Each one is borrowed from an OSHA rule, an NEC working-space table, or an air-insulation withstand table, and most of the distances are sums — a basic electrical clearance plus an allowance for the fact that people move.
Column 1: Voltage Ranges Built on Maximum Voltage
The voltage ranges in Column 1 group together voltages that need similar approach distances. The grouping criterion is the sum that sits behind the whole table: the electrical withstand distance plus an inadvertent movement factor. Voltages whose sums land close together share a row.
The top of each range deserves attention. The upper limit of a range is not the nominal system voltage — it is the maximum voltage for the highest nominal voltage in the range, taken from ANSI C84.1, Electric Power Systems and Equipment — Voltage Ratings (60 Hz). A “480 V” system does not actually sit at exactly 480 V all day; ANSI C84.1 recognizes the maximum voltage such a system can reach, and the table rows are drawn so the system is covered at its worst, not at its nameplate.
One conversion rule handles single-phase systems. For a single-phase system, you select the range equal to the system’s maximum phase-to-ground voltage multiplied by 1.732. That multiplier is the familiar √3 relationship: it converts the phase-to-ground figure onto the same basis the ranges were built on, so a single-phase system is not accidentally placed in a lower row than its insulation stress deserves.
Column 2: OSHA’s 10 ft Rule
Column 2 gives the limited approach boundary as it applies to unqualified persons, and its basis is a flat OSHA rule: unqualified persons maintain 3.05 m (10 ft) of clearance for all voltages up to 50 kV (voltage-to-ground). Above that, the rule grows in steps — add 0.10 m (4.0 in.) for each 10 kV over 50 kV. So the column is not a curve fitted to test data; it is a regulatory clearance rule with a simple arithmetic extension, which is why the distances feel generous compared with the qualified-person columns. They are meant to protect people who cannot recognize or react to the hazard.
Column 3: Borrowed From the NEC Working-Space Tables
Column 3 — the limited approach boundary for qualified persons around fixed equipment — comes from the NEC working-space tables, and C.2.1.3 names exactly which one applies in each band:
| Voltage band | Basis for Column 3 |
|---|---|
| ≤750 V | NEC Table 110.26(A)(1), Working Spaces, Condition 2, for the 151 V to 600 V range |
| >751 V to ≤145 kV | NEC Table 110.34(A), Working Space, Condition 2 — using 751 V instead of 1000 V for the lowest voltage range |
| >145 kV | OSHA’s 3.05 m (10 ft) rules, as used in Column 2 |
Two details hide in that table. First, the basis is Condition 2 in both NEC tables — the middle working-space condition, not the most or least generous. Second, at the bottom of the 110.34(A) band, 70E substitutes 751 V for the NEC table’s own 1000 V starting point, so the medium-voltage working-space distances begin right where the low-voltage table leaves off instead of leaving a gap. Above 145 kV, the borrowing stops and Column 3 falls back on the same OSHA 10 ft rules as Column 2.
Column 4: Withstand Distance Plus Inadvertent Movement
Column 4, the restricted approach boundary, has the most engineering inside it. Its distances are based on OSHA 29 CFR 1910.269, Table R-6 for voltages of 72.5 kV and less, and Table R-7 for voltages above 72.5 kV. Behind both sits the general statement of C.2.1: the distances in the tables include dimensions added to a basic minimum air insulation distance, and those basic distances come from OSHA’s 29 CFR 1910.269, Table R-3.
So a restricted approach distance is a sum of two components. The withstand distance is the air gap that will not flash over at the system voltage — the purely electrical part. The inadvertent-movement factor is the human part: an allowance for the worker leaning, slipping, or reaching farther than intended. Neither component alone is a safe working boundary. Air that withstands the voltage does nothing about a stumble, and a movement allowance means nothing if the remaining gap can flash over.
The 1 ft Exception at 151–750 V
One row of Column 4 is deliberately not the straight OSHA sum. OSHA’s Table R-6 arithmetic for the low-voltage range adds a small withstand distance — 0.02 m (0.07 ft) — to the 0.31 m (1 ft) inadvertent-movement distance, giving 0.33 m (1.09 ft). NFPA 70E assumes the withstand distance for voltages of 750 V and less is negligible, so the restricted approach boundary for 151 to 750 V is set at 0.31 m (1 ft) rather than 0.33 m (1.09 ft). The difference is tiny, but it shows the table was assembled by judgment on top of the source data, not copied blindly.
Worked Scenario
A qualified electrician is planning work at an exposed 480 V three-phase panel and wants to know where the restricted approach boundary in Table 130.4(E)(a) actually comes from — not just the number, but its parts. She works through the C.2 logic. First, the row: 480 V nominal falls in the 151–750 V range, whose upper limit reflects the maximum voltage for that nominal class under ANSI C84.1 (and because her system is three-phase, the ×1.732 single-phase conversion does not apply). Second, the restricted distance from Column 4, built on OSHA Table R-6: the inadvertent-movement factor for this range is 0.31 m (1 ft), and the withstand component at 750 V and below is treated as negligible — so the sum is simply 1 ft. Had she used OSHA’s unrounded arithmetic, she would have added the 0.02 m withstand allowance and gotten 1.09 ft; 70E’s table gives her 1 ft. Third, she sanity-checks the limited approach boundary she will brief the crew on: Column 3 for this voltage comes from the NEC’s Table 110.26(A)(1) Condition 2 working-space distance — the same depth the installer was required to leave in front of the panel. Every number she briefs now has a source she can name.
Common Mistakes and Safety Notes
- Treating the table numbers as arbitrary. Each column has a named source — OSHA clearance rules, NEC working-space tables, or OSHA 1910.269 withstand tables. Knowing the source tells you what the distance does and does not protect against.
- Forgetting the ×1.732 rule for single-phase systems. Single-phase systems are placed by maximum phase-to-ground voltage × 1.732; skipping the multiplier can put the system in too low a row.
- Using nominal voltage to pick the row. The range limits are maximum voltages per ANSI C84.1. A system belongs to the row that covers its highest nominal voltage at its maximum, not its nameplate value on a good day.
- Assuming Column 4 is pure electrical clearance. It is withstand distance plus an inadvertent-movement factor. Working right at the boundary leaves no allowance for the movement the number already assumes.
- “Correcting” the 1 ft boundary to 1.09 ft. At 151–750 V, 70E intentionally assumes a negligible withstand distance. The table value is 1 ft; OSHA’s 1.09 ft is the unadjusted source figure.
- Mixing up the column sources. Column 2 is OSHA’s flat 10 ft rule; Column 3 is NEC working space; Column 4 is OSHA 1910.269. They answer different questions for different people.
Summary
Annex C.2 shows its work. Column 1 groups voltages that need similar approach distances, with each range topped by the maximum voltage of its highest nominal voltage under ANSI C84.1, and single-phase systems placed by maximum phase-to-ground voltage × 1.732. Column 2 is OSHA’s rule for unqualified persons: 10 ft up to 50 kV, plus 4 in. for each 10 kV above that. Column 3 borrows the NEC working-space tables — 110.26(A)(1) Condition 2 at low voltage, 110.34(A) Condition 2 (starting at 751 V) up through 145 kV, then the OSHA 10 ft rule again. Column 4 rests on OSHA 1910.269 Tables R-6 and R-7, summing a Table R-3 air-insulation withstand distance with an inadvertent-movement factor — with one deliberate exception: at 151–750 V the withstand distance is assumed negligible, making the restricted approach boundary 1 ft instead of OSHA’s 1.09 ft.
Quick-Check Questions
- What is the upper limit of a voltage range in Column 1 based on?
Answer: The maximum voltage for the highest nominal voltage in the range, based on ANSI C84.1. - How is a single-phase system placed in the voltage ranges?
Answer: By the range equal to the system’s maximum phase-to-ground voltage multiplied by 1.732. - What is the basis for the Column 2 distances?
Answer: OSHA’s rule that unqualified persons maintain 10 ft of clearance for voltages up to 50 kV, plus 4 in. for each 10 kV over 50 kV. - Which NEC tables supply the Column 3 distances?
Answer: Table 110.26(A)(1) for voltages up to 750 V and Table 110.34(A) above that (both Condition 2), with OSHA’s 10 ft rules used above 145 kV. - Why is the restricted approach boundary for 151–750 V 1 ft rather than 1.09 ft?
Answer: NFPA 70E assumes the air-insulation withstand distance at 750 V and less is negligible, so only the 0.31 m (1 ft) inadvertent-movement distance from OSHA Table R-6 is counted.
Based on NFPA 70E (2024), Informative Annex C, paraphrased for study.
Video lesson for this module is in production — coming soon.
Quiz for this module is being prepared.
Flashcards for this module are being prepared.



