
What You’ll Learn
- Why electrical safety has to be holistic: installation and work practices are separate undertakings, and each shapes the other for the life of the equipment
- What risk means in this standard — a combination of the likelihood of injury and the severity of that injury
- The six risk management principles and the six parts of the risk management process adapted from ISO 31000
- Why risk assessment itself is only two moves — risk estimation and risk evaluation — and why it is incomplete without context and an objective
- Where risk assessment sits inside an occupational health and safety management system: the leadership–policy–plan–do–check–act cycle
Two Undertakings, One Safety Problem
Installation and work practices both affect electrical safety, but they are separate and distinct undertakings. Safe work practices are not part of making an installation de-energized, and installation is not a safe work practice when a worker is exposed to electrical hazards. That separation is why Annex F opens with a demand for a holistic approach. Designers have to consider the safety of the people who will operate the equipment and the people who will maintain it. Employers have to run risk assessments before finalizing the selection and installation of equipment, addressing both operation and maintenance. There are thousands of ways to design or install a piece of equipment while still complying with product standards and NEC requirements — but only one design and one installation method actually get used, and that choice has a lasting impact on electrical safety for the entire life of the equipment. There is no limit to the voltage, current, or energy a safe installation can contain; once an employee is exposed to those hazards, there can be no hindsight about how the equipment was designed or installed. Done holistically, design and installation account for justified employee exposure and for the methods of controlling it, so future employees are protected twice over: by the installation itself and by NFPA 70E safe work practices.
What “Risk” Means Here
In a general sense, risk is the potential for a chosen action — or inaction — to lead to some type of loss or injury. For electrical safety, the annex narrows that down: risk is a combination of the likelihood of the occurrence of injury and the severity of the injury that results from a hazard. The injury, direct or indirect, can come from contact with exposed energized circuit parts or from an arc flash event. The hazards in view are the electrical ones the standard addresses — electric shock, arc flashes, arc blasts, and burns from hot electrical equipment associated with a task — together with the risks attached to them, management system deficiencies, opportunities for improvement, and the PPE the task requires. The annex is careful about one boundary: electrical safety issues, not health issues, are the focus of this standard, even though both matter to overall safety.
Risk Management: A Logical, Systematic Process
Risk management is the logical, systematic process used to manage the risk associated with any activity, process, function, or product — safety, environment, quality, and finance included — and organizations of any type or size can use it. Section F.1 lists six principles that carry over directly to electrical safety. Risk management:
- Is an integral part of all organizational processes and decision making
- Is systematic, structured, and timely
- Is based on the best available information
- Takes human and cultural factors into account
- Is dynamic, iterative, and responsive to change
- Facilitates continual improvement of the organization
Two of those principles do quiet work throughout the rest of the standard. “Based on the best available information” is why an assessment built on guesses about equipment condition is weak, and “dynamic, iterative, and responsive to change” is why an assessment is never truly finished — conditions change, and the assessment has to change with them.
The Six Parts of the Process
The risk management process itself has six parts, adapted from ISO 31000:
- Communication and consultation
- Establishing the risk assessment context and objectives
- Risk assessment
- Risk treatment
- Recording and reporting the risk assessment results and risk treatment decisions
- Monitoring and reviewing risks
Notice where risk assessment sits: third, not first. Before anyone estimates a risk, the process calls for talking to the people involved and for fixing the context and objectives. After the assessment comes treatment — deciding what to do about the risk — then documenting the results and decisions, then monitoring and reviewing. Risk assessment is one station in a loop, not the whole journey.
Risk Assessment = Estimation + Evaluation
Risk assessment is the part of risk management that involves identifying sources of risk, analyzing those sources to estimate a level of risk, and evaluating that level to determine whether risk treatment is required. Put in the annex’s own framing, risk assessment is made up of risk estimation and risk evaluation: it is the determination of the level of risk related to an actual situation involving a recognized hazard. Risk control then works the hierarchy of controls from the highest level to the lowest to bring the risk down to an acceptable level for the task at hand — and the whole procedure is iterative, a process of risk reduction repeated until an acceptable risk level is attained. Two basic approaches to structuring an assessment exist — the hazard-based approach and the task-based approach — and Annex F addresses them separately in F.4 and F.5, with assessment methods in F.6.
Context and Objective Come First
For risk to be properly assessed, the situation must be placed into a specific context and the objective must be defined — without either one, a risk assessment is incomplete. The same exposed hazard can produce different assessments depending on the objective: an assessment aimed at arc flash protection can legitimately differ from one aimed at electric shock protection. Context also decides whether a risk exists at all. An exposed hazard introduces the risk of injury, but if employees are not permitted to enter a room, there is no risk of personal injury from what is in it; permit them in, and the risk greatly increases. And the reverse caution applies too: not all tasks close to hazards pose an increased risk of injury. Exposure, task, and objective together frame the assessment — which is why “establishing the context and objectives” earns its own step in the process before any estimating begins.
The Management System Around It (F.2)
Risk management does not float free of the organization. Section F.2 ties it to an occupational health and safety management system (OHSMS) — the framework Annex P develops — because a management system provides a methodical approach to health and safety through goal setting, planning, and performance measurement. Risk management shares the system’s six process elements:
- Leadership — any venture needs sponsorship at the highest levels of the organization to succeed
- Policy — the organization articulates its vision and establishes relevant, attainable goals
- Plan — a plan is developed in line with the vision and goals, with mechanisms to measure and monitor its success
- Do — the plan is executed
- Check (Monitor) — the plan’s success in achieving the goals is continuously monitored
- Act (Review) — results are compared against the goals so goals and plans can be reviewed and revised to improve performance
That is the plan-do-check-act (PDCA) cycle, and risk management’s iterative character mirrors it — the repeating cycle exists to promote continuous improvement in health and safety performance. Risk assessment fits into the cycle at two points. In planning, information comes from sources that include workplace inspections, incident reports, and risk assessments. In do, risk assessment is an ongoing activity, not a one-time planning artifact. The assessment you write before the job and the assessment you keep doing while conditions change are the same discipline at two stages of the loop.
Worked Scenario
A plant is replacing a motor control center lineup. The electrical manager could treat the purchase as a pure installation decision — meet the NEC, meet the product standards, done. Instead she runs the holistic process. Before finalizing selection, the team establishes context and objective: the objective is freedom from harm for both operators and the maintenance crew who will rack breakers and troubleshoot for the next thirty years; the context includes justified energized diagnostics that cannot be designed away. The risk assessment identifies the sources of risk in the candidate lineups, estimates the level of risk for the tasks each design would create, and evaluates whether treatment is required. The evaluation changes the purchase: the specified lineup includes design features that reduce exposure during maintenance, because the assessment was done before the equipment was chosen, while the design could still change. The results and the treatment decisions are recorded and reported, the new lineup enters the facility’s monitoring and review cycle, and the whole exercise sits inside the site’s management system — leadership sponsored it, policy set the goal, and the plan-do-check-act loop will revisit it after the first year of incident reports and inspections.
Common Mistakes and Safety Notes
- Treating installation and work practices as the same undertaking. They are separate and distinct; a compliant installation does not make exposed work safe, and safe work practices do not fix a design that creates needless exposure.
- Starting with the estimate. The process puts communication and consultation, then context and objectives, ahead of risk assessment. An assessment without a defined objective is incomplete by definition.
- Forgetting that the objective changes the answer. An assessment for arc flash protection can differ from one for shock protection on the same equipment — name the objective before arguing about the result.
- Doing the assessment once. Risk management is dynamic and iterative; monitoring and reviewing risks is a named step of the process, and risk assessment is an ongoing activity in the “do” stage.
- Assessing after the equipment is bought. Employers are to conduct risk assessments before finalizing selection and installation — after installation, the design decisions that shape exposure for the equipment’s whole life are locked in.
Summary
Annex F frames risk assessment as one part of risk management, and risk management as one part of running safety holistically — installation and work practices treated as the separate undertakings they are, with design decisions made knowing they will shape exposure for the life of the equipment. Risk is a combination of the likelihood of injury and the severity of that injury. The risk management process runs in six parts — communication and consultation; establishing context and objectives; risk assessment; risk treatment; recording and reporting; and monitoring and review — under six principles that stress good information, human factors, and iteration. Risk assessment itself is risk estimation plus risk evaluation, and it is incomplete without a specific context and a defined objective. Around all of it sits the occupational health and safety management system, whose leadership–policy–plan–do–check–act cycle houses risk assessment in both planning and doing.
Quick-Check Questions
- Why does Annex F insist installation and work practices are separate undertakings?
Answer: Because safe work practices are not part of a de-energized installation and installation is not a safe work practice under exposure — each must be addressed on its own terms, holistically. - How does the annex define risk for electrical safety?
Answer: As a combination of the likelihood of the occurrence of injury and the severity of the injury that results from a hazard. - What are the six parts of the risk management process, in order?
Answer: Communication and consultation; establishing the risk assessment context and objectives; risk assessment; risk treatment; recording and reporting results and decisions; and monitoring and reviewing risks. - What two components make up risk assessment?
Answer: Risk estimation and risk evaluation — determining the level of risk for a situation involving a recognized hazard, then judging whether treatment is required. - In the PDCA cycle of an OHS management system, where does risk assessment fit?
Answer: In planning, where assessments are among the information sources, and in “do,” where risk assessment is an ongoing activity.
Based on NFPA 70E (2024), Informative Annex F, paraphrased for study.
Video lesson for this module is in production — coming soon.
Quiz for this module is being prepared.
Flashcards for this module are being prepared.



